Sell to Us

Thank you for making Game Haven your favorite place to buy, SELL and play! Your collection is our priority, and we're excited to offer you fair value for your collection.

For accurate Trade-In Sales, Game Haven will directly review your cards at our storefront for an in-person assessment. 

We recommend scheduling a time with us Mon-Fri anytime from opening and before 7pm, when our Weekly Events begin. Walk-ins are welcome.

To set up an appointment, please email gamehavenmd@gmail.com

  • Pricing Structure: We operate trade-ins on a sliding scale. We offer around 50% of the TCG Market price in Cash or 60% in Store Credit. Amounts may vary based on individual card value and condition. 

  • Trade-In Scheduling: You have the option to reschedule or leave your collection with us if we have a queue. If you choose, you can leave your collection with us and we will give you the value amount in both Cash & Store Credit. Cash and check payments are available.


Trade-In Instructions & Details

We kindly ask for you to consider the following steps before bringing your collection to us.

  • Card Presentation: Please remove all cards from binders and make sure they are unsleeved before trading them in.
  • Organization - MtG: Please sort out Rares & Mythics, as well as Commons & Uncommons valued at over $0.50 (based on TCGplayer's market price). Any cards that are not sorted per instructions may be considered Bulk and may be purchased based on our Bulk Rate for MtG singles.
  • Sealed Product: These items require management purchase. 
  • Large Collections: Please email ahead if you're trading in a sizeable collection of any product, as well as for all Sealed Product.

We handle multiple collections daily and aspire to give your collection the attention it deserves.


Exclusions

  • We will not accept Severely Damaged cards (water, soil, tears, holes, etc).
  • In some cases, we may make exceptions for Signed or Altered cards.
  • Please notify us if your collection has been stored in a space with pets, as some of our team members have Pet Allergies.

Thank you for choosing Game Haven for your collectible sales! 

Please Contact Us with any additional questions.